The Cat's Meow Movie Critic
Home Page
Occasional reviews of the best of the cinematic arts by Chicago film critic, Carl Zapffe

The Cat's Meow Movie Critic

Read hundreds of Carl Zapffe's past movie reviews from 2000 to 2008 at:

Archived Movie Reviews

NOTE: While I wish to concentrate on writing book reviews for my Cat's Meow Book Nook web site,

Cat's Meow Book Nook

Mini movie reviews will still occasionally be posted here as time and inclination warrant.

Mini-Reviews of Movies Recently Seen:

"EASY VIRTUE" ... This modest film adapted from a minor Noel Coward play

will delight all Anglophiles in addition to pleasing others for its exquisite casting and strong performances by Kristin Scott Thomas and Jessica Biel. A mother (Thomas) and a bride (Biel) at an English country house during the late 1920's fight over the heart and soul of John Whitaker (Ben Barnes), the young son and heir, after he returns home with his new bride who turns out to be (Gasp!) a brassy American, a young widow, an independent woman, and a race car driver! 


The grand estate soon fills with tension. John's two younger sisters quickly side with their mother, but the feelings of John's dad (Colin Firth), a one time bon vivant, are left open to question. Due to developing events, the young couple are forced to stay longer than they had originally planned, just long enough for devastating secrets to spill out on both sides.


With Jessica Biel looking positively ravishing, it might appear to be an unequal battle between the mother and her new daughter-in-law, but don't count this dour mistress of manipulation out. Kristin Scott Thomas plays to perfection her role as an ice queen, while Jessica Biel continues to show a real flair for period costume dramas after this and her earlier fine role in "The Illusionist." (B+, go see it.)


-------------------------------------


"STAR TREK" ... It is always a thrill to see a new version of this storied franchise hit the silver screen, but this iteration has been wildly overrated (#94 on IMDB's Top 250? Come now!).  I found the film to be a great disappointment. The story tries to cover too many subplots and it ends up giving short shrift to all of them. There was enough material here for three movies. 


In addition, this film commits one of my pet peeves by using jerky handicam motion as a substitute for actual physical action, especially in its many fight scenes. This quickly becomes very tiring as it is, in essence, a visual copout.  


The film does offer many complimentary asides to earlier versions of "Star Trek," including the television series, and it is generally well cast with young stars who will probably come back again and again as did their forebears. Seeing Leonard Nimoy again was a treat, but I did miss seeing William Shatner. The basic story line offered possibilities, but it needed a blue pencil to pare it down to its essence. (B, save it for free television.)


----------------------------------

"EARTH" ... Disney ought to be ashamed of themselves for putting out these recycled images in a messy and nearly incoherent cut and paste job. It seems that Disney is trying to cash in by leveraging every single asset that they have. 


For example, midway through this movie lush scenes of the Okavango Delta are shown, and then a reference is made to their headwaters up in the distant mountains. Suddenly, the scene shifts from Africa all of the way to the Himalayan Mountains in India and then half way around the world to the Angel Falls in South America without any explanation or narrative. Admittedly dramatic visuals, but from three different continents with nary a rhyme or reason...


Yes, the scenes are beautiful, but any aficionado of the Discovery Channel or Animal Planet has seen many of these very same scenes before. David Attenborough did it far better in his excellent series. (B, Skip this movie and rent David Attenborough.)


----------------------


"STATE OF PLAY" ... This Washington, DC political murder mystery perhaps aspired to be a modern rendition of the classic political thriller, "All the President's Men." While an entertaining and thoughtful movie made for adults, it, sadly, has been a flop at the box office ($36 Million) in spite of its top flight cast including Oscar winners Russell Crowe and Helen Mirren. Ben Affleck, Rachel McAdams, Robin Wright Penn, and Jeff Daniels round out the stellar list of costars. 


Affleck plays a populist congressman whose lead research assistant mysteriously falls to her death right before his hearings on a corporation charged with domestic espionage. Old style pen and paper reporter (Crowe, looking disheveled and long-haired) bristles at being teamed up with young gossip columnist and blogger (Rachel McAdams) for the followup on this story by his editor (Helen Mirren). As it happens, the congressman (Affleck) and the reporter (Crowe), are former college roommates who know each other well. Too well, it seems, as he lost his college sweetheart (Wright Penn) to the up and coming congressman. Publicity from the hearings appears to have provoked a shadowy cadre of former military snipers to settle things their way. (A-, See it and rent it.)


----------------------------------


"I LOVE YOU MAN" ... The premise is somewhat captivating: a guy (Paul Rudd) who is a girlie-man, metro sexual, or whatever you wish to call him, flounders around on the eve of his wedding when it comes to selecting his best man. Here is a guy who hangs out with the girls and feels that "The Devil Wears Prada" is an outstanding movie. Maybe he should see "The Shawshank Redemption" once or twice? His problem is exacerbated by the fact that his coworkers at a real estate office are either sleaze balls or left without any definition to further the dubious plot line. 


This movie would fail were it not reasonably well written and beautifully cast. Rudd plays Peter Klaven and Rashida Jones is utterly captivating as his lovely fiancée. Equally captivating are her parents, played by Jane Curtin and J. K. Simmons. Jaime Pressley amps up the heat as Zooey's best friend, Denise, and Jason Segel plays the role of a schlump of a man with a real heart to raunchy perfection. Even "Hulk" Lou Ferrigno has several cameo scenes.  Let's face it - It is hard not to be swayed by the innate appeal of this movie when everyone in it is so sincere and likable. This movie is less raunchy than advertised, although certainly deserving of its R rating. I liked it, but found that it dragged in parts. The writing needed to be tightened up and several unnecessary scenes should have been deleted. (B, rent it.)

 

crash_poster.jpg

The Top 10 Movies of 2005

million_dollar_baby_poster.jpg

The Top 10 Movies of 2004

mysticriverposter.jpg

The Top 10 Movies of 2003

talktoherposter.jpg

The Top 10 Movies of 2002

amelieposter.jpg

The Top 10 Movies of 2001

crouching_tiger_hidden_dragon.jpg

The Best Movies of 2000

chinatown_poster.jpg

My Top 10 Picks of the Greatest Dramas of All Time!

young_frankenstein_poster.jpg

My Top 10 Picks of the Funniest Comedies of All Time!

all_about_my_mother_poster.jpg

My Top 10 Picks of the Greatest Small Gems and Romantic Comedies of All Time!

Requests for Publication and Reproduction Rights

web site hit counter

Last updated on